none of the news today really fits this forum so heres an evergreen one that bugs me...
every year the site puts out a list of topics and its stuff like "AI", "geopolitics", "the economy", "security". thats it?? you could stick those words on any conference on earth. and then it's the Chatham House rule so nobody can say who said what, no minutes, no recordings, no press inside...
so the only public record is a short topic list and a list of names. ok. but if the topics are that broad, they could be deciding literally anything under each heading and we'd never know. thats not an agenda, thats a category label!!
my suggestion: everyone grab a few years of the published topics and compare to what governments and central banks actually did in the 12 months after. not claiming proof, im saying lets look at the pattern with our own eyes... maybe it's nothing, maybe not.
so what do you think, is a vague topic list just normal for a private meeting, or is it deliberately designed to tell us nothing??
Look, a vague topic list is just how these things work, you don't publish your playbook for a private meeting. Okay. Vague doesn't mean it's secret plotting, it means nobody wants to be quoted, and I'd rather have that than a press conference full of nonsense.
Voilà, the pattern-spotting exercise is a fine idea, though I suspect the published lists would fit most governments' year-end statements just as well. Vague topics are mostly a sign of a club that does not want to be held to its words, which is a fair criticism, and I say that as someone who thinks it should be more transparent.