ok so ive been reading through the central bank design papers again and something keeps bugging me. the ECB digital euro prep phase, the bank of england digital pound consultation, the PBoC e-CNY pilots. every one of them talks about privacy as a feature but also about "programmability" or conditional payments in some form. the e-CNY has been used in pilots for things like expiring stimulus vouchers, thats not a conspiracy, its in public reporting
from an engineering view this is the problem. you build rails where the issuer can see and condition every transaction, then you promise youll only use it nicely. thats a policy promise sitting on top of an architecture that makes abuse trivial. policy changes after the next crisis, architecture stays
and yes i know cash is declining anyway and card networks already see everything. but visa seeing my coffee purchase is not the same as the state being able to flip a switch on the money itself
so whats the actual upside for regular people that cant be done with fast payment systems like FedNow or UPI? or is the whole thing just about central banks not wanting to get cut out of payments by private stablecoins? convince me otherwise
you build rails where the issuer can see and condition every transaction
yeah the expiring vouchers thing is the bit that gets me. sounds small, like ok cool your stimulus dies in 30 days, but its the same switch just pointed at something else later. I mean nobody builds a lever for the nice use case and then forgets it exsits. or whatever, maybe im overthinking, its 9am and im on my second coffee
edit: that coffee was on a card btw so visa knows too. not helping my case lol
ok i need to vent for a sec because this thread is getting my blood pressure up. everyone keeps saying "its just a voucher, it expires in 30 days, relax" and like... THATS the trick?? the small friendly use case is always the one they sell you first. nobody ever says "hey we're building a lever that can freeze your savings." they say "we're making sure pensioners get their heating money on time" lol
and the "experts" keep saying programmability is just a design choice. ok, sure, so is every lock. the question isnt what they promise today, its who holds the key in
Which pilot has actually been used to freeze someone's savings, as opposed to expire a voucher? Those are two very different claims, and only one of them is in the public record so far. And who is the key-holder you have in mind: the ECB, the Bank of England, or whichever government happens to be in office?